Rated 2.0 out of 5.0Â by BLAAAAASK Cons outweigh Pros
I'll start out with the pros I found of the Healthy Volume Mascara. It really doesn't clump, which is nice. The volume part seems to work right. My way to wear this is to put Healthy Lengths on first and then quickly coat Healthy Volume on top, giving you not only long eyelashes, but thick ones as well. This is good for a very vampy look. The carbon black is my favorite if you're going for that vavavoom!
Cons: Smudgy! It seems to get all over, and since it is waterproof it is very difficult to get off. The mascara does eventually 'fall' and create a darkness under the eyes, especially from flaking. It is unimaginably horrible to get off, even with makeup remover. After a thorough washing, I still have clumps of mascara attached to my lashes and flakes floating in my eyes. Not something I want to deal with every day! Also it has caused quite a lot of my eyelashes to fall out which I have not experienced with other mascaras before.
In general: If you don't mind the hard clean-up or flakes, like for a night out or a fun party, this will work decently. But every day wear is a no in my opinion.
Jan 12, 2016
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0Â by MakeUpUser97 AMAZING
This mascara works amazing at the pool and the beach. dosnt smear off. and keeps my mascara looking fye.
Apr 11, 2015
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0Â by sassysue Great lashes
I really love this mascara. I have really sensitive eyes and can wear this without any problems. It also makes my eyelashes look so long and full. Have recommended this to others who have sensitive eyes. My friends ask if I am wearing fake lashes.
Feb 22, 2015
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 Best mascara for thin lashes
I discovered this after losing most of my lashes during chemo for breast cancer. When you only have a few lashes, a mascara that makes the most of the ones you have is essential!! That was four years ago and this is the only mascara I will use.
Jan 10, 2015
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0Â by meialisse very good mascara,
I absolutely love it. I had been looking for the best mascara out in the market, and this mascara has met my expectations of what a good mascara should be like. it goes on smoothly.
Aug 19, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0Â by BreeLove122 The best mascara I've tried!
I have tried a LOT of mascaras. Most of them leave me with clumpy lashes, especially the waterproof ones. This mascara is the first that hasn't done that. It works beautifully and is my go-to beauty product. I use this every day! It's definitely worth trying out.
Oct 28, 2013
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0Â by Katy Not Happy
I use a lot of Neutrogena products. This mascara is terrible! It is very dry to put on. It does nothing to lengthen my lashes. I am not happy. :(
May 27, 2013
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0Â by CATLADY NOT WATERFROOF!
I have worn waterproof mascara for years as a
contact lense wearer. This product runs and smudges
worse than non waterproof. There is nothing
waterproof about it, I LOVE Neutrogena products
and am disappointed. This is the worst waterproof mascara I have ever had.
Mar 13, 2013