Rated 5.0 out of 5.0Â by meialisse very good mascara,
I absolutely love it. I had been looking for the best mascara out in the market, and this mascara has met my expectations of what a good mascara should be like. it goes on smoothly.
Aug 19, 2014
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0Â by BreeLove122 The best mascara I've tried!
I have tried a LOT of mascaras. Most of them leave me with clumpy lashes, especially the waterproof ones. This mascara is the first that hasn't done that. It works beautifully and is my go-to beauty product. I use this every day! It's definitely worth trying out.
Oct 28, 2013
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0Â by Katy Not Happy
I use a lot of Neutrogena products. This mascara is terrible! It is very dry to put on. It does nothing to lengthen my lashes. I am not happy. :(
May 27, 2013
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0Â by CATLADY NOT WATERFROOF!
I have worn waterproof mascara for years as a
contact lense wearer. This product runs and smudges
worse than non waterproof. There is nothing
waterproof about it, I LOVE Neutrogena products
and am disappointed. This is the worst waterproof mascara I have ever had.
Mar 13, 2013
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0Â by mascara mama Disappointed
I can't believe I have to say this, because this is the first Neutrogena product I have been disappointed by. The mascara is sticky and is extremely hard to remove. I know that it is waterproof, but it takes many applications of eye makeup remover before it starts to come off.
Feb 7, 2013
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0Â by Peberly Love Love Love!
this product is:
- my favorite waterproof mascara at the moment.
- very waterproof, if you want a mascara that will stay on all day, its great.
- very thick and has an unusually dry formula, which i personally don't mind because my lashes don't stick together while its drying. and i have not noticed any flaking throughout the day like many people have been saying.
- A bit tough to remove, but what i do is use liquid eye makeup remover with a cotton round to remove all my eye makeup each night before i get in the shower. i do not experience "raccoon-like" circles under my eyes after or when i wake up the next morning
- great by itself but i usually apply the "healthyvolume" waterproof mascara and then over top, i apply "healthylengths" washable mascara.
- OVERALL has a few flaws but i like the product and have been repurchasing it for the past year and a half.
Nov 27, 2012
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0Â by TLC05! It's not perfect but I still like it...
Every waterproof mascara I have ever used bothers my eyes, but this one is doesn't irritate my eyes at all. It's pretty water proof no better than any others, it does flake after several hours but again they all do that. I know a lot of people have issues removing it but baby oil ( yes, I said baby oil, if you wash your face afterwards it won't break you out) removes it and the Pond's wipes work well too. It's a good mascara and I'd purchase it again
Nov 19, 2012
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0Â by NaturalKnockout Love it!
I know this product has bad ratings but I decided to purchase it yesterday anyway. I was looking for a waterproof but natural mascara that wouldn't bother my sensitive eyes. I have bad allergies year round. When I applied it, the large brush made it easier actually and wasn't bothersome. It went on smoothly and didn't clump. My eyes were irritating me today but only when I was around cats, which I'm allergic to, so undone think the mascara bothered my sensitive eyes. I only wore it today for 4 hours. The last hour I was cuddling with my boyfriend and my eyes were watering from laying down on my side but it never smudged or ran. When I removed it, I wanted to test it so I put some water on my fingers and rubbed my eyes to see if it would smudge or run. It didn't until I rubbed them roughly, the second time and it was only minimal and barely noticeable even up close. Then, I anticipated if being difficult to remove. I only had pure cold pressed coconut oil around so I used it as a mascara remover. It worked well and seemed to remove it completely. Then I washed my face. Afterwards, I pulled gently on my lashes to see of any product would come off still and there was none. I don't expect to have raccoon eyes in the morning. I didn't experience any problems that other people experienced and I expect to be falling in love with this mascara! I'm glad I gave it a try!
Oct 14, 2012