Rated 2.0 out of 5.0��by greenquetzal13 Not a fan...
I used to buy Neutrogena's eye shadow quads and soothing eye shimmers and really liked them. I was pretty bummed when they discontinued them. I decided to try one of these crease proof shadow sticks and am not impressed. The staying-power of these is notable, but they aren't entirely crease proof--by the end of the work day, I had a tell-tale crease on both lids. They also need to offer more colors--a nice neutral brown, a deeper grey and/or nude colors would be nice to have. Oh, and they're also a bit too shimmery for me...
Nov 24, 2013
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0��by Forever.Lorelei Works great!
I have noticed as I age (I am in my 40's) that the skin on my eyes is starting to look crinkly if I use a powdered eyeshadow with glitter. This shadow has a little glitter, in small particles, that adds a nice highlight to the eyes without looking crinkly or overdone. I have it in several shades. Best part about it? It's darn near fool-proof. Just glide it on, smudge a little with your finger to soften the edges and you are done! It glides on easy, no pulling or dragging the skin. It blends nicely; as it dries it sets so it has all-day staying power.
Buy it. You won't be sorry. =)
Nov 17, 2013
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0��by PINKlove34 My eyes are gorgeous!
This crease proof eye shadow is AH-MAZING! It truly is crease proof, and it lasts all day. I have the constant copper one. You can wear it alone for daytime, then add different colors for a great smoky eye look. I LOVE this product! I'm buying more colors soon :)
Sep 20, 2013
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0��by Marjie Taupe
I haven't used Neutrogena eye shadows since they quit making the fairy dust duo. Was very apprehensive about trying this, since creams tend to aggravate my eyes. This blended well, stayed on all day with no irritation. It looks natural, showing up a lighter brown than I thought. Will try the plum next.
Aug 29, 2013
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0��by Koujokakyuu More colors, or I will try other brands. :(
I am a makeup novice, so I started with Neutrogena's eyeshadow because I trust the brand and thought the application seemed fool-proof. I like the taupe, which I picked because it was a nice neutral to complement blue/grey eyes. However, I would really like to try some other shades, and of the ones offered, I'm really only interested in the platinum. Can you offer a charcoal grey? That's really a no-brainer for a smoky eye. I'd also like to try a pale turquoise and a richer blue, maybe a lapis lazuli.
Aug 23, 2013
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0��by carolinagirl Good formula but not color choices
I really like the taupe, but not the other colors. The formula and price are great, but please offer a soft, nude color for the lid. The stay golden is too "gold" and the pink is too "pink." I believe another reviewer said the same thing.
Jul 19, 2013
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0��by Karla Really is crease proof!
For a few weeks now, I've been using Neutrogena Crease-Proof eyeshadow in taupe on the baggy part of my eyelids, and it really is crease-proof. Even in hot, sweaty Texas!
Jul 12, 2013
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0��by racingfan39 Pretty color
This was not crease proof but I still like the product and would buy it again. The color is very pretty just be sure to blend in every couple of hours because it does crease.
Jul 2, 2013