Rated 1.0 out of 5.0��by DaytonGirl Too much mascara on the brush.
I tried this for the first time and there was so much mascara on the brush that I couldn't use it. I wiped some of the mascara off before putting it on my lashes and a TON of mascara was on my lashes that made them look ridiculous and stuck together. I threw the mascara away after that. Worst mascara I've ever tried and I've tried several different brands.
Oct 23, 2013
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0��by EmBen IN LOVE!
I naturally have long full lashes and when I try to use another brand of mascara its way too much...yikes... this just does the trick. not too much and not too little. it also gives my eyes a brighter look!
Oct 2, 2013
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0��by Tamm Love it
My eyes are really sensitive and this mascara is awesome. It gives them length, color, and definition. Most makeup even super expensive brands for sensitve eyes make my eyes itch, water, and get red and puffy, but not this one. Love it!!!
Sep 10, 2013
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0��by Daisy105 Love this!!!
I don't get why people don't like this, I love it! It makes my eyelashes longer and darker which makes it perfect for a natural look. I think this product is better for younger teens since it doesn't create dramatic lashes I also noticed my lashes are thicker and longer after I take it off which is a plus! Thanks for another great product Neutrogena!
Jul 11, 2013
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0��by CBloom Liked the old formula better
I used the mascara in a the white tube. When I needed more, I bought the new black tube. This one was unlike the white formula. This product did not cover well and did not lengthen the lashes as well as the original formula. I would not recommend this product they way it is now.
Jun 8, 2013
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0��by New & Improved. Updated review...
My previous review from "New is not better" gave this mascara a low rating. But I made a mistake. After two days of using this new mascara I was indeed disappointed but I decided to just finish it up and low and behold on the third day of using this new mascara again something happened. I dunno if I just got the hang of the brush or whatever but my lashes just looked totally stunning. Long, evenly spread and classy. Totally acceptable for day time use. I now truly believe that I prefer this updated version as the white tube would sometimes create raccoon eyes. However this newer version gives me long, good looking lashes without the clumps. Keep on trying ladies as ones you get the hang of how to use this new mascara you might like it as much as I do.
May 24, 2013
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0��by Anonymous My eyes are not irritated and broke out
This is the first time I used Neutrogena mascara. it's affordable. I'm tired of spending money at the dept. stores. It doesn't clump nor is it drying and stiff. My lashes are soft but still could use more oomph. I read the comments about going back to the old formula. If you do, make it so that we who have sensitivies can wear it. I like that you can use soap and water/cleanser to wash it off. Saves money not having to buy eye makeup remover.
May 21, 2013
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0��by New is not better. New formula is not better.
The white lengthening mascara tube was just excellent. I am getting tired of companies constantly changing their products. Why did you have to change the formula? The new mascara version is horrid. It does not lengthen my lashes in fact it does nothing. Neutrogen why oh why are you constantly changing a good thing? Sigh, now I have to look elsewhere.
May 19, 2013